This Broad Land

This started as another piece with another title. Ursinus College asked me to compose a short work honoring President John Strassburger on his retirement, and the key to the piece came from his own writings. In his essay on Abraham Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address, he makes a point about the flexibility of Lincoln’s poetic voice. Strassburger quotes these words from an earlier Lincoln speech, the first inaugural address of March 4th, 1861:

The mystic chords of memory, stretching from every battlefield and patriot grave to every living heart and hearthstone all over this broad land, will yet swell the chorus of the Union, when again touched, as surely they will be, by the better angels of our nature.

There’s a piece here, I thought. “The better angels of our nature” became the focus and title, and I composed a chant-like beginning to an ethereal work. Trouble started, though, when I started hearing chords under this chant-snippet, two chords, actually, the tonic in root position followed by the tonic in first position,

an unremarkable progession, but heard to great effect in Puccini’s La Bohème*

all the way to the piano coda of Clapton’s “Layla,”**

with, I confess, #2 sticking in my head the most. So, this was a chant no longer, but a tune with accompaniment. The angels slowly ascended to another (perhaps future) piece, and as I worked out the tune, it became less angelic-sounding, less ethereal, and broader, more determined.

The angels ushered in other spirits, though, the spirits of Gettysburg and Independence Day, whose anniversaries were barely a week after the 26 June 2010 premiere. It may be making too much of it, but I feel that this is a peculiarly American work, inspired by Lincoln, echoing a British guitarist immersed in Southern rock, and an Italian opera on a French subject, written for the Midwest-born president of an originally Pennsylvania German college.

Bassoonist Jeffrey Centafont accompanied by John French performed this with great sensitivity, and I was almost overwhelmed by the warmth of the reception by those assembled for President Strassburger’s honor. I’ve already transposed this for performances on soprano saxophone, and believe that any number of instruments might play this successfully.

* To tell you the truth, I don’t actually know what that second Puccini chord is. Sometimes it sounds like a tonic major 7th (with that tonic E delayed all the way to the third beat), and sometimes like a simple mediant (with that melodic E just a pedal holdover). It depends, as with much chordal analysis, on your point of view, I suppose, which is why I bother with chordal analysis, I suppose, very seldom.

** In the lead sheet that 2nd bar is a Cmaj7, but I always hear that with E in the bass, don’t you? And actually, I read that the coda was written by drummer Jim Gordon.

4 thoughts on “This Broad Land

  1. John Strassburger

    Dear Kile ( if I may):

    I was bowled over by your introduction of the piece you wrote in my honor, your research into my writings and most of all by the simple, but yet rich music you created. I cannot thank you enough. It was the big surprise of the evening, and both my memory of it plus the score are things I will treasure forever. I had an uncle, howard boatwright, who was a composer, and we talked long hours about the process. It was always somewhat magical and mysterious to me, but he made it clear that it was also a lot of very, very hard work. Well, your work was brilliant; I know of no other word that suits better. I cannot thank you enough for turning a special evening into an astonishing one.

    1. Kile Smith Post author

      Dear John,

      I had no idea you were related to Howard Boatwright, a very fine composer! Also (and this speaks volumes), he was highly thought of by one of my favorite composers, Paul Hindemith, who, although a likable fellow by all accounts, was quite economical in his praise of other composers.

      I was truly honored to have been a part of your evening, but I must say, I was not prepared for the profound appreciation and utter gratitude shown by everyone there for all you have done, and all you have meant, for the Ursinus community. My wife Jackie and I were staggered by the deep and heartfelt expressions from all facets of the College, and have talked about it often since. I glimpsed a shadow of it in preparing the composition, but I am so glad that the writing of it allowed me the bonus of witnessing this. With my fond regards,


  2. Priscilla

    What a small world!

    I listened to Layla the other day – that B section theme was one of my favorite pop licks in high school, but I didn’t ever try to analyze then. Now I see it really IS cool. I feel so validated! 🙂

    Your thought progression in starting this piece sounds a lot like how you started Vespers.

    Congrats on your many recent successes. I’ll raise ein bier to you tonight!


Leave a Reply