Monthly Archives: August 2011

Plain Truths "the high point": The Boston Musical Intelligencer

William Lloyd Garrison

Plain Truths, just premiered at the Newburyport Chamber Music Festival, picks up a nice review in The Boston Musical Intelligencer, the journal and blog of the classical music scene in Boston. Sudeep Agarwala likes the “early-American sound-world” of the ballads and “harmonically complex backdrop” of other songs, and calls the second song, “Annie Lisle,” “particularly heart-rending.” Read the entire review here.

Plain Truths in the Boston Globe

Joel Brown writes in the Boston Globe about the upcoming premiere of Plain Truths:

…“These seacoast people see the world and learn,’’ the Gothic novelist Harriet Prescott Spofford wrote about Newburyport.

Turns out they hear and learn, too.

The words of Spofford and other writers with ties to the area will be in the air at the 10th annual Newburyport Chamber Music Festival, running Saturday through Aug. 20.

A festival highlight will be the Aug. 20 world premiere of composer Kile Smith’s “Plain Truths’’ for voice and string quartet, featuring the words of Spofford, abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison, songwriter Henry S. Thompson, and the inimitable local character “Lord’’ Timothy Dexter. The cycle of five songs, bookended by Garrison, is the festival’s gift to the city according to artistic director David Yang.…

“I wanted a composer that I knew and trusted to write something really terrific,’’ Yang said last week. “And second of all, I wanted just someone I liked personally, because the composer comes up, and the thing about the festival is that they’re not only the best musicians we can find in the world, but also people are good human beings that the audience likes and gets to chat with. And lastly I knew Kile has a special experience with text. He’s written for voice a lot.’’… It will be sung by bass baritone Jeremy Galyon, an up-and-comer at the Metropolitan Opera.…

For details and tickets,

Smith's 'Truths' looks at Port's past

JC Lockwood’s appraisal of the upcoming premiere of Plain Truths, my failed poetry, and my burgeoning pop career, in his blog Newburyport Arts. A taste:

…But sometimes the Philadelphia-based composer takes the word thing almost to the point of obsession: By the time he gets around to writing the music, he sometimes will have spent months digging through biography and history, selecting and rejecting and editing texts. … “Plain Truths,” a 20-minute piece for baritone and string quartet based on texts of prominent Newburyporters from the community’s storied past, including the pot-boiling 19th-century novelist Harriet Prescott Spofford, the fiery abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison, and of course, self-appointed Lord Timothy Dexter, who presided over High Street, if nothing else. In fact, the title of the piece, which gets its NCMF premiere on Aug. 20, comes from Dexter’s “A Pickle for the Knowing Ones; or Plain Truths in a Homespun Dress,” an 1802 work that is part political screed, part sermon and part diatribe against anyone who owed him money… As usual, Smith got caught up in the history, especially the Dexter — so much so that he considered building the whole piece around just this one of the city’s most colorful figures…

Plain Truths

To mark the Tenth Anniversary of the Newburyport Summer Music Festival, Music Director and violist David Yang wanted to commission a work as a special thank-you to the Festival’s home. We decided that a song cycle for baritone and the resident string quartet, featuring texts by Newburyport authors, might be a significant addition to the week’s concerts.

Of the few early suggestions, writings of the self-titled “Lord” Timothy Dexter leaped to the fore. A Pickle for the Knowing Ones, or Plain Truths in a Homespun Dress is delightfully brusque, impassioned, whimsical, and completely innocent of pretense. It is part political screed, part sermon, and part diatribe against anyone who owed him money. Dexter was a barely literate laborer who, through street smarts and astonishing luck in trading, amassed a fortune, giving him entrée into bemused society. His book is a remarkable chunk of writing. It was tempting to give the entire cycle over to Dexter, but he does occupy the middle song of five.

Further research uncovered many possibilities, but I quickly decided on “Annie Lisle,” a popular song by the otherwise unknown Henry S. Thompson. It was so successful that the tune became the melody for dozens of college alma maters. I avoided listening to the music until after composing this, as I had in mind an original tune, which nevertheless is in the mold of a 19th-century American salon piece.

The abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison bookends the cycle, with powerful preaching from his newspaper The Liberator. I quote from the very first and last issues: his 1831 shot across the bow proclaiming his rejection of moderation in the fight against our national tragedy, to his 1865 valedictory, which followed the Thirteenth Amendment’s official eradication of slavery. “I am aware” is an angry recitative; “Spirit of Freedom,” a marching hymn.

That leaves No. 4, “Oh, Andrew,” by the Gothic romantic Harriet Prescott Spofford. It was a choice that surprised me, but which became, I believe, the emotional center of the cycle. Its melodrama mirrors that of No. 2’s “Annie Lisle.” The singer takes on the personas of the girl, the boy, and the narrator, accompanied respectively by the violins, the viola with cello (which invert the violins’ music), and then all together. I was fortunate in the choice of bass-baritone Jeremy Galyon to bring this and all the songs to life.

The cycle is written in admiration for the people of Newburyport, about whom Spofford wrote, “These sea-coast people see the world and learn.”

Commissioned by the Newburyport Summer Music Festival, David Yang, Music Director, with partial support from Meet the Composer. Premiered August 20th, 2011, Jeremy Galyon, Baritone, and the Newburyport Festival String Quartet.

Update, 13 Nov 2013

The new, expanded version premieres November 16th at the Newburyport Chamber Music Festival with baritone Randall Scarlata, the Festival String Quartet, and The Candlelight Chorale, Jay Lane, Music Director. David Yang, the Festival’s Artistic Director, is also the Quartet’s violist.

The songs are for baritone and string quartet, but now have a chorus on four of the seven for this new unveiling (but optional thereafter).

For baritone and string quartet, it is now seven songs, from five, and includes optional chorus on the two new songs and on two of the older ones. It clocks in at about 30 minutes. I originally set texts from authors who lived in Newburyport in past centuries.

The two new texts are more contemporary. Tom Coleman, who died only six years ago, wrote “Remember Meho?” for a book of town reminiscences. “Homing In” is from a poem by longtime local newspaperman Bill Plante.

Plante’s is a heartfelt longing for a time and for friends that are past. I was struck by its poignancy, but surprised by the same emotion coming to me from Coleman’s, after it first eluded me. I’m so happy to have had the chance from Newburyport to revisit this.

1. I am aware
I am aware that many object to the severity of my language; but is there not cause for severity? I do not wish to think, or to speak, with moderation. No! No! Tell a man whose house is on fire to give a moderate alarm; tell him to moderately rescue his wife from the hands of the ravisher; tell the mother to gradually extricate her baby from the fire—but urge me not to use moderation in a cause like the present. I am aware, and I will be heard.
—Wm. Lloyd Garrison (1805–1879), from The Liberator (1831) 

2. Annie Lisle
Down where the waving willows
’Neath the sunbeams smile,
Shadowed o’er the murm’ring waters
Dwelt sweet Annie Lisle;
Pure as the forest lily,
Never thought of guile
Had its home within the bosom
Of sweet Annie Lisle.

     Wave willows, murmur waters,
     Golden sunbeams, smile!
     Earthly music cannot waken
     Lovely Annie Lisle.

Sweet came the hallowed chiming
Of the Sabbath bell,
Borne on the morning breezes
Down the woody dell.
On a bed of pain and anguish
Lay dear Annie Lisle,
Changed were the lovely features,
Gone the happy smile.


“Raise me in your arms, O Mother;
Let me once more look
On the green and waving willows
And the flowing brook.
Hark! the sound of angel music
From the choirs above!
Dearest mother, I am going;
Surely God is love.”

     —Henry S. Thompson, 1857 

3. Plain Truths
     I will tell the type of mankind, what is that 35 or 36 years gone by, about a town called Newbury. Newbury people kept together quietly until the learned grew strong.
     The Ignorant or the Knowing Ones says I ought to do as they do to keep up cheats or the same thing, deceptions. Deceive so we may cheat and likewise have wars and plunder. My wish is all liars may have their part of fire and brimstone in this world or else the government is not good—it will want purging soon.
     If you can bear the truth, I will tell the truth. I am a friend to all honest men.
     Our ministers are imported. I would keep them. I wish the priests knew as much as I think I do. I see God in all places: the God of Nature in all things. We live and move in God. Take one element from us, take the fire or the water or air or earth, we are gone. So we live in God. Now let us all be good children, do all things right. All in Love. I say, keep together. Newbury people kept together until the learned grew strong. Like the boxwood in my garden, never fade. Man is the best animal and the worst.
     If you can bear the truth, I will tell the truth. I am a friend to all honest men.
     —Lord Timothy Dexter (1748–1806), from A Pickle for the Knowing Ones; or Plain Truths in a Homespun Dress (1802) 

4. Remember Meho?
Remember Meho? He met every train and was at every parade with his camera. He snapped pictures everywhere, but never had any film in the camera.
—Tom Coleman (1928-2007)

5. Oh, Andrew
     “Oh, Andrew, it was so splendid of you!”
     “What was so splendid of me?”
     “Standing by him so, standing by the captain when the others left—bringing home the ship!”
     “Well, is this all? Ain’t you going to shake hands with me? Ain’t you glad to see me?”
     “Oh, Andrew! So glad!” and she turned and let him see the blushing, rosy face, the large, dark, liquid eyes; then overcome, as a sudden shower, the long-lashed eyelids fell, and the face was hidden in a storm of tears. And then, perhaps because he was a sailor, perhaps because he was a man, his arms were round her and he was kissing off those tears, and the little happy body was clinging to him and trembling with joy. As for Andrew—he had not known that he cared for her so much until she turned that tearful, rosy face upon him; now it seemed that he had been hers since time began: he said to himself, and then repeated it to her, that he had loved her always.
     —Harriet Prescott Spofford (1835–1921), from Louie (1872) 

6. Homing In
Under the roof tops,
beneath the chimney pots,
six thousand of homes,
ninety miles of streets,
fourteen thousand of people
My city, by the measure.

And by their names:
Roberts? Jackman? O’Brien? Jones?
Connolly? Matthews? Boyjian? Welch?
Coltin? Naumetz? Foley? Smith?
Lyons? Moynihan? Roberts? Doyle?
Johnson? Murphy? LeClair? Cox?

Porky, Butch, Boomer,
Red, Sqwaboo, Sonny
and all the rest calling
across the steaming
summer afternoons.

My City born of mountain
streams led to salt
of sea and marsh,
of glacial soil, and those
who fished the toil of those
come to labor of men and
women in shops shaping
skins to shoes, molasses
to rum, thread to linen,
and silverware for
High Street tables.

My City born of street games—
“Fox in the water, all come across!”
“My goal, one-two-three!”
“Allee Allee in freeeeee!”

My city swimning
through the river waste
on dog day afternoons.

My city calling
across the curbs,
along the wharves,
over the fences,
beneath the scarfing rooftops,
the smoking chimney pots
among the old wards,

calling to all who knew her

through the years
now leaving shadows
in the rising sun.
—Bill Plante (b. 1921), from “Homing in on Once Upon a Time” (2002)

7. Spirit of Freedom
Spirit of Freedom! on—
Oh! pause not in thy flight
Till every clime is won
To worship in thy light:
Speed on thy glorious way,
And wake the sleeping lands!
Millions are watching for the ray,
And lift to thee their hands.
Still Onward! be thy cry—
Thy banner on the blast;
And, like a tempest, as thou rushest by,
Despots shall shrink aghast.
On! till thy name is known
Throughout the peopled earth;
On! till thou reign’st alone,
Man’s heritage by birth;
On! till from every vale,
And where the mountains rise,
The beacon lights of Liberty
Shall kindle to the skies!
     —Wm. Lloyd Garrison, from The Liberator (1865) 

Here’s my recounting of the 2013 premiere of the new version, here’s my preview of that concert, here’s my Broad Street Review article about making the piano reduction, here’s my update about finishing the new version, here’s a description of the two new songs added, here’s my recounting of Jeremy Galyon singing some of it at a summer 2013 concert with piano, here’s my looking forward to that concert, here’s a review of the 2011 original in the Boston Musical Intelligencer, and here’s the preview of that concert in the Boston Globe.

Ignaz Pleyel, Dmitri Shostakovich

Saturday, August 6th, 2011, 5:00-6:00 p.m.

Ignaz Pleyel had three strikes against him during the French Revolution. He was rich, he was a foreigner, and he worked for the Church. He was exactly the type of person for whom the Reign of Terror sharpened its guillotines. Even worse: He was an artist. Different despots use different tactics, but artists are usually among their first targets.

The Austrian Pleyel was Director of Music at the Strasbourg Cathedral, leaving for England in 1791 when the Revolution banned public and church musical performances. His London concert series actually competed with that of another Austrian in the city at that time, Joseph Haydn, who had been Pleyel’s teacher. They remained good friends despite the competition and even played each other’s music on their concerts. They also made a lot of money there, and Pleyel bought a chateau from his windfall when he returned to France after his concerts ended. But the Revolution was just getting started.

Churches were outlawed. The Cathedral was renamed the “Temple of Reason,” and Pleyel was brought before the Committee numerous times, charged with being an enemy of the Republic, an enemy of the people. Others had been executed for less, so he began to write works praising the new government, such as The Revolution of August 10. He became a citizen. It all had the desired effect, and “Citoyen” Pleyel was left alone as the Reign of Terror ended and France began its climb back from the horrors of repression.

He continued to compose, and the clarinet concerto we hear today comes from this time. He became a successful music publisher, inventing the miniature score and printing music of his contemporaries, including Haydn’s string quartets. He founded the Pleyel piano manufacturing firm, and Pleyel pianos are still made today. As for his music, well, everybody played it. He was so popular that Nantucket Island had a Pleyel Society, and American hymnals included his tunes. He is buried in a parcel of land with perhaps the highest concentration of famous gravesites, the Père Lachaise Cemetery in Paris, just a few paces from one of his piano customers, Frédéric Chopin.

The story of Dmitri Shostakovich is more well-known. Other composers had already fled a USSR still consolidating power in the 1920s, but in the ʼ30s Stalin turned his full attention to modernists–these new enemies of the people–not aligned with his vision of the ideal citizen. Shostakovich’s triumphs piled up, though, until Stalin came to his already successful opera Lady Macbeth in 1935. The dictator was not pleased. Its brutal story was realistic, but it was not Soviet Realism and besides, Stalin shuddered every time the loud brass came in. The critics dutifully bashed it.

Fearing for his life, Shostakovich withdrew the dissonant Fourth Symphony, about to be premiered. He continued to write film music, which was useful propaganda for the regime, and then his putatively Soviet-affirming Fifth Symphony helped return him to good graces in 1937. His career from then on swung back and forth between prizes and denunciations. In another crackdown against the “formalist” avant-garde, his professorships were revoked from the Moscow and Leningrad conservatories in 1948. A mild-looking but fiery 21-year-old student cellist at Moscow quit in protest. Mstislav Rostropovich would later premiere both of his teacher’s concertos. The first, written in 1959, was recorded in Philadelphia, with the composer in the recording booth, under the eyes of wary apparatchiks.

Tyrants of every century all seem to think that composers have something so important to tell us, they need to be watched. Maybe they’re on to something. Let’s listen.

On the first Saturday of the month Jack Moore and I host Discoveries from the Fleisher Collection on WRTI 90.1 FM in Philadelphia and on the all-classical webstream at We also broadcast encore presentations of the entire Discoveries series (now nine years and counting!) every Wednesday at 7:00 pm on WRTI HD-2. For a look at all the shows, click here.

Mr Dumas, I have your nomination

Mailed to me at work. I was this close to being in “the most elite professional network in the world”:

Dear Mr Ralph Dumas: On behalf of International WHO’S WHO of Professionals, I am pleased to inform you that you have been nominated… We congratulate you! …an honor in itself… the most elite professional network in the world… It is in times like these that such a network is most valuable… I urge you to act today… Board of Advisors… Eurobrokers-Greece; Eastern and Southern African Trade and Development Bank-Kenya; Citibank, N.A.-Great Britain; Abdu Dhabi Investment Company-UAE; Volvo Car-Russia; Hyundai Motor Company; Bulova Watch International, Ltd.; Shell Brasil… If you wish to unsubscribe…